Quantum advantage

We discuss the importance of reducing errors in quantum hardware in order to achieve practical quantum advantage.

A few years ago at Silicon Valley's Churchill Club, IBM's director of research, Arvind Krishna, was asked a question: "For quantum, which is the tougher problem to solve? Getting the hardware right or building software that works?"

It's a bit of both, but getting the hardware right is probably more critical. Because if the hardware's not right, the software ain't gonna help you.

Arvind Krishna, Director of Research – IBM

At Q-CTRL we bring something extra to the table. While the hardware engineers are working to build better physical systems, we are producing firmware that can drive down error rates on existing - and future - platforms. Even better, our significant techniques can relax the demands on the poor, overworked hardware engineers in a virtuous cycle.

That means Q-CTRL's solutions are bringing the era of useful quantum technology closer.


In 2019, Google reported that it had achieved quantum supremacy using a system with just about 50 qubits. Soon after, IBM simulated a 56-qubit processor using a classical computer, pushing the boundaries of what is needed to display quantum supremacy, the tipping point at which a quantum system probably solves some problem, any problem, outside the reach of classical algorithms.

Despite the mild controversy, the claim stood - Google had built a quantum computer that performed a task that was practically impossible for even a large-scale supercomputer. A couple of years later, this early demonstration was matched by two teams in China (though they used slightly different descriptive language as the term “supremacy” engenders some unwelcome racial connotations and became contentious within the community).

Google's Sycamore chip is kept cool inside their quantum cryostat. Image by Eric Lucero/Google, Inc.
Google's Sycamore chip is kept cool inside their quantum cryostat. Image by Eric Lucero/Google, Inc.


For starters, it marked an astounding scientific demonstration in the field of quantum computer science.

That said there is further subtlety to explore. Science magazine described the importance of this milestone, but added "But it will be years before quantum computers have enough power and reliability to achieve some of the much-hyped practical applications of such machines."

For many end users of quantum computers, quantum advantage is the milestone that matters most - the circumstance where quantum machines begin solving practical problems for real-world applications faster or cheaper than their classical counterparts. That is, doing something useful.

Even the most optimistic projections for the size and complexity of quantum computers able to solve problems of practical utility remain out of reach for today's devices. Q-CTRL enables teams to extract more performance from their quantum hardware, accelerating the pathway to useful systems.

Professor Michael Biercuk, Founder and CEO – Q-CTRL


The Boston Consulting Group suggested in 2019 that it’s less than a decade away. But in order to get there, we still have to improve the usefulness of the underlying hardware.

A few years ago, Professor John Preskill from Caltech introduced the concept of NISQ: Noisy Intermediate Scale Quantum Computing.

Although we probably won’t be able to use full-blown quantum error correction to protect NISQ-era devices from noise, we should design near-term quantum algorithms with noise resilience in mind. Clever design of noise-resilient algorithms may extend the computational power of NISQ devices.

Professor John Preskill, Caltech

The quantum firmware layer within the quantum computing software stack.
The quantum firmware layer within the quantum computing software stack.

This is exactly what Q-CTRL is doing now: building clever noise-suppressing quantum firmware to extend a quantum computer’s computational power. And all of this comes well before "full-blown" quantum error correction is ever needed.

There remains much work to be done in the research community. But many markers are pointing in the right direction, and progress has continued at breakneck speed. Quantum firmware is moving the needle to help us go even faster.

If you’d like to understand more about how quantum firmware intersects with quantum error correction, you can read more information about it in our piece in IEEE Spectrum.


Take the next step on your journey with short articles to help you understand how quantum computing and sensing will transform the world